3 Minute Tips / Sentry Shorts

What It Really Takes to Open an Ice Cream Business

Posted by Robert Romarino

Jun 20, 2025 10:07:28 AM

Many aspiring entrepreneurs dream of opening an ice cream shop, but the path to profitability isn't always as sweet as it seems. Before diving in, it's crucial to understand two fundamental questions: "What will it cost me?" and "What will I make?"

 

 

Beyond the Dream: Understanding the Costs

The number one reason businesses fail isn't poor location or a bad concept; it's being undercapitalized. This often stems from a lack of understanding regarding the true costs involved. As consultants, our role extends beyond selling equipment; we educate customers on the financial realities.

The cost of opening an ice cream business varies significantly based on your concept.

  • Store Type: A 2,000-square-foot walk-in store requiring extensive decor will naturally cost more to build out than a 500-square-foot walk-up window.
  • Product Sourcing: Are you making your own ice cream, or buying wholesale? Making your own requires additional equipment like batch freezers, hardening cabinets, and dipping cabinets, increasing your initial outlay.
  • Aesthetics and Finishes: Everything from lighting fixtures (which can range from $50 to $500 per light) to flooring (tile from $2 to $10 a square foot) and countertops (imported quartz versus Mica) will impact the overall cost of your store. While a beautiful store is desirable, the focus should be on the product itself, as customers pay for the ice cream, not just the decor.

By understanding your vision, concept, and potential location, we can extrapolate these costs to provide a clear financial picture.

Realistic Expectations: What Can You Truly Make?

Once you understand the costs, the next question is, "What can you make?" It's essential to have realistic expectations. Dreaming of $500,000 in profit in your first year in an ice cream business is generally unrealistic. We aim to mitigate risk and increase your chances of success, recognizing that "success" itself is subjective and depends on the individual.

Several factors influence your potential revenue:

  • Operating Season: Being open year-round will affect your revenue compared to a seasonal operation.
  • Product Offerings: Selling hard ice cream and waffle sundaes at a higher price point will generate more revenue than typical soft-serve or Italian ice. Gelato, for example, commands an even higher price point.
  • Operating Hours and Days: The number of days and hours you're open annually directly impacts your sales.
  • Location Demographics: A store in a high-end area or a shore town where a cone might sell for $8 will have different revenue potential than one 20 miles inland where the same cone sells for $4.

We utilize spreadsheets to help customers understand profit potential by inputting rent, fixed costs, estimated labor, and food costs. This allows for a clearer picture of profitability based on your specific vision.

The Importance of "Why"

Ultimately, opening a business isn't just about dollars and cents; it's often about lifestyle or building a legacy. That's why we always ask new customers, "Why are you doing this?" Understanding your "why" helps us guide you in the right direction.

While dealing with experienced consultants doesn't guarantee success, it significantly increases your chances. We've been in the business since 1981 and have helped open thousands of stores. Our goal is to ensure you have enough capital based on your vision and understand the profit potential, so you can make an informed decision to pursue your ice cream dream.

 

 

the do's and don'ts of starting an ice cream business